Thursday, October 6, 2011

Religion = Art = Religion

 Art is the central form of communication of religion. Art gives us the power to express emotions and ideas powerfully. It also allows us to pass religious traditions down from generation to generation. 


Geertz's definition of religion states that religion is "A system of symbols which acts to establish powerful, pervasive, and long lasting moods and motivations." The definition of art is "The expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power." The potential emotional power of art is practically the only way to suitably portray the emotions that religion makes us feel. That is why there have been cave paintings, statues and music throughout the years used to define religions all over the world.


From this...
...to this.  (BWV 244b/29a)
The oral tradition of song has helped cultures pass on myths and tales revolving around their religion. The songs of many cultures have gone unchanged for centuries and centuries and are still around today. Sometimes, songs go through changes, intentional and unintentional. There were lots of simple hymns in Catholic church around the time of J.S. Bach, and he took the melodies of those hymns and made them into his collection of chorales. Physical art such as paintings and statues are more permanent in a way; obviously they (sometimes literally) more concrete then passing down tradition word of mouth. however paintings and statues corrode and songs can change so much that meaning is lost, so it is hard to say that the methods are the best for keeping something alive, however they capture the emotion and pervasive power of religion better than any written record.




However, you could ask, what came first? art, or religion. I find it likely that art and religion are one and the same. When our brains developed this ability and lingering to believe in higher beings and when we became so curious about the world and developed a drive to find an answer to everything (causal reasoning) I imagine that this is also the time that the creative, artistic aspect of humans came about. Also, some of the earliest art we know of has religious contexts (The Caves of Lascaux). Since religion is a means of explaining the world around us and the uncertainty of everyday events, and art is a means of expressing the creative skill and imagination of humans it makes sense that art is commonly used to express religious thought and ideas. And this explains why it is the most effective way of expressing people's strongest religious beliefs and this would also explain why it is such a universal way of religious  expression.

4 comments:

  1. I think you did a wonderful job supporting the idea that art and religion are one in the same. Also, I am very intrigued by this idea. It seems that people are on a constant search for what came first when really there are many things that feed off of each other. Very interesting post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think you have a really interesting idea here. While I can agree that it seems very likely (especially after you laid it out so well here) that religion and art developed in a sort of symbiotic way, I think that it's also important to note the distinctive natures that the two have taken on in this modern time. For example, there are many pieces of art that seem to have no religious meaning (it doesn't necessarily mean that there isn't one, but it's not obvious), or songs that specifically bash religion. In the realm of religion, there are a lot of religions that discourage any form of artistic outlet, such as dance. None the less, I think you make a very good point, and it's certainly worth thinking about.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Being a musician myself, it is really nice that you like to talk about music in your blog posts. I definitely agree with you that religion and art came about at the same time. I think in the society we live in, we tend to make too many distinctions. We like to separate religion with politics, and religion with culture. It's a modern idea that is quite common in western culture. I am taking a music history course all about the music of Bali, and in their society, music, art, poetry, drama and religion are all mixed together and it has been like that for thousands of years.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I enjoy your continuing use of free blog to mine theme of art and religion. Not sure why fonts get changed ,I'd-way through.. Keep that consistent.

    ReplyDelete